The Middle Park Hotel development was at Victorian Civil and Administration Tribunal (VCAT) last week, after another 4 days, a further 3 days have been scheduled for 13th to 15th March 2024. 

VCAT Tribunal Members described multiple times the dynamic as 'complex', they are acutely aware of the case's public profile, that the issue is 'highly contentious' and its importance to the Middle Park community.

Example highlights last week:

• Under cross examination AVC's acoustic expert divulged that he was told by his client, AVC, that the rooftop was intended as a 'sports bar' - not a 'food led, high quality dining experience' as communicated to Council and national media.
• AVC's submitted plans fail to adequately explain how a new roof terrace will sit directly on top of the existing pitched roof structure - no engineering solution provided.
• PMPV submitted into evidence expert covert undercover surveillance material regarding the majority of AVC's other Melbourne rooftop bars - not one single piece of food to be seen at other AVC venues - only loud music and alcohol being consumed by 18-30 year olds.
• AVC / MPH had been operating unlawfully since the end of June - no valid permit for the MPH pavement area. The Middle Park Hotel, despite knowledge of this fact, has declined to close this area temporarily. (Editor's note: MPH received a valid permit within 24 hours of the complaint).

Thank you to local residents who attended in person.